Mulit Purpose
2009
Book Review: “churchill & the Jews”
Martin Gilbert is a historical writing phenomenon; a historian without peer in many areas; and an intellectual giant in Churchilliana. Again he has produced another valuable niche product in the vast compendium of Churchill related works, this one centred on Churchill’s 70-year relationship with Jews, Zionism and post 1947 Israel. Even if you are not found of Churchill, the book should be read by those who desire to know more about the Middle East, the current Israeli-Arab struggle, and why in modern times, Israel was created as a backdrop to current events; Gilbert has produced a valuable canvass.
I have read all of Gilbert’s works, and pretty much everything there is on Churchill, and this book served up two pleasant surprises. The first, is the not inconsiderable politically incorrect pro-Zionist narrative found in Gilbert’s prose acted out by Churchill’s 70-year affinity for the cause of ‘Jewishness’ and Zionism. When world ‘opinion’ and outrage is so consumed by sympathetic revisionism seen in pro-Arab, pro-Palestinian and extreme tolerance towards all things Muslim, it is heartening to read intelligent reality based commentary which disavows genuflection to the Arab-Islmaic-Mulit-Cult, anti-modern program. The second surprise was to read of Churchill’s constancy in his support of Jews, in spite of political opprobrium over so many decades. He even once described Judaic ethics as, “incomparable the most precious possession of mankind, worth in fact the fruits of all other wisdom and learning put together.” The gutless political wonders of today wouldn’t have the courage or intellectual understanding to utter such a thing. Besides the Arab feminist gay vote would cry and be pouty. It takes a rare man to stand so long on principle even as political and public ‘opinion’ support erodes.
But neither Churchill nor Gilbert are ordinary men. Churchill’s career, as Gilbert highlights, is one intertwined with, and supportive of, ‘Jews’ and Zionism, especially the idea of a Jewish home, where the long persecuted race could find security and safety. Churchill always rejected, ‘the anti-semitic lines of prejudice’ both in and outside Britain, feeling that with applied intelligence and patience, Jews and Arabs could peaceably prosper in a flourishing and modern Palestine. Unfortunately the Arabs then as now, show little inclination to live in the modern world.
From 1904 to 1908 Churchill, the 30 to 34 year old politician represented a minority Jewish constituency in Manchester. Jewish concerns were thus imprinted upon Churchill’s world view early in his career. As Gilbert elaborates, Churchill during his lifetime had many Jewish friends, publishers, researchers, political allies, and even financiers. (Churchill almost went bankrupt in the 1930’s, saved by the intervention of some notable Jewish families). As a Cabinet Minister in 1921 and 1922, charged with determining the future status of a Jewish home in Palestine; through World War Two and the holocaust, as Prime Minister from 1951-1956; and as a historian puzzling over the relationship between Jews and Arabs; Churchill was profoundly associated with Jewish concerns and the complexity of Arab Jew interaction in Palestine.
Though fond of Jews (and too fond according to one critic), Churchill was at times evisceratingly critical of Jewish extremism or inflexibility. Not surprisingly Churchill knew of the depth of Jewish leadership in the Russian bolshevist movement (all top Bolsheviks, including Lenin were indeed at least partially Jewish), calling upon Jewish leaders to denounce bolshevism and instead elevate true Jewish ethics instead. Likewise during the 1930s and 1940s, when fringe Jewish terrorist groups were attacking and murdering British Subjects and innocents in the Palestine mandate, Churchill adjured Jewish leaders to strike down such evil elements lest a Jewish home became a political and social impossibility.
In short, if you analyze his career and statements, Churchill was not Hitler’s caricature of a drunken, Jewish knave, promoting capitalism as the smiling, materialistic face of neo-imperialist slavery. He was instead a politician who believed in the Judeo-Christian tradition and who had the power to help realize Britain’s 1917 Balfour Declaration guaranteeing Jews a Palestinian home (done to gain support of Jews in Russia and America to prosecute the war against Wilhelmina Germany). If you look at the historical record, the Jews owe Israel’s very existence, at least in part, to Churchill’s exertions.
In 1922 Churchill as a Cabinet Minister responsible for Palestine, produced the Churchill White paper; which laid the foundation of an Israeli State. Churchill’s White Paper, which addressed the partition of Britain’s mandate between Arabs and Jews (Palestinians were a separate ‘people’ created by the U.N. and Arabs circa 1967), was decidedly pro-Zionist, allocating perhaps 12% of the mandate to the Jews and 88%, including present day Jordan, some of Syria, and current ‘Palestinian’ holdings to the Arabs. In terms of geographical coverage the Arabs won in terms of legitimacy, the Jews had their necessary and powerful, political support. Churchill’s plan was to increase civilizational development for 1000 years. As Churchill commented, the Arabs had done nothing with the land. As Jews increased from 80,000 people in 1922, economic development would dictate the levels of Jewish emigration. It was Churchill’s hope that the 500,000 Arab residents in 1922 would not feel overwhelmed by a rising Jewish population.
As it turned out he need not have worried. By 1948 the Arab population in the British Mandate had tripled from 1922 levels to 1.5 million. The Jewish population had surged to about 800,000. Upon declaring statehood in 1948, post-British withdrawal, the tiny Jewish State was attacked by 5 Arab States with 50 times the population. Israel survived of course, humiliating the Arab armies. (It is a cautionary tale. However, for those who chatter about precipitate withdrawal from Iraq or Afghanistan, those Western allied governments will simply collapse if the West exits).
Gilbert’s book is in many ways required reading for our days and times. There is nothing wrong as Churchill’s example attests to, of having constancy and moral purpose in politics. Defending the Jews- a vital part of Western civilization- is noble and just. Affirming blame to Arab-Islamic intolerance when analyzing Middle-Eastern affairs is necessary and justified. Learning from Churchill, from history, and from cultural precedents is also to be embraced.
About the Author
Churchill and the Jews is one known connection in this great man’s life story. The life of Churchill is peppered with issues and stories about how he was a great defender of the Jews.
paper18 12 08 0131 mulit purpose stun gun
|
|
Presto 06003 Options Electric Multi-Cooker/Steamer $30.99 Options, Multi Cooker/Steamer, Roasts, Stews, Steams, Boils & Deep Fries, Accommodates Large Roasts, Ham & Poultry, Control Master Heat Control Maintains Proper Cooking Temperature Automatically, Fully Submersible With Heat Control Removed, Heavy Cast Aluminum Body With Deluxe Nonstick Surface Inside & Out, Includes Tempered Glass Cover & Steam/Fry Basket…. |
|
|
Big Boss Multi Blender The 15-Piece Hi Speed 300-Watt Personal Countertop Blender Mixing System $40.24 The Big Boss Blender Multi Blender System is a must have for every kitchen. The 15pc. System features 3-18oz. Large cups with three matching comfort rings, six assorted lids, Recipe Booklet and one stainless steel blade attachment. A design so versatile, it chops vegetables, blends smoothies, grates cheese, grinds coffee, mixes soups, batters, cocktails and so much more…. |
|
|
All-Clad Stainless 12-Quart Multi Cooker with Steamer Basket $146.49 Reach for the All-Clad 12-quart multi-cooker whenever you cook up a big batch of pasta, a mess of corn on the cob, or clams for a crowd. Oven-safe to 500 degrees F, the multi-cooker comes with riveted stainless-steel handles. The included pasta basket and steamer basket feature lift-out handles to simplify draining and can be set aside if you are cooking soup or chili. The bestseller among All-Cla… |
|
|
5 straigt MUSTACHE + NOSE HAIR SCISSORS mulit-purpose w/safety tips $4.81 The precision cutting blades with rounded,curved safety tips are made from fine raw materials,tempered,hypoallergenic stainless steel used for surgical instruments,hardened for extra-strength and enhanced with chromium for superior rust protection…. |
|
|
5 curved MUSTACHE + NOSE HAIR SCISSORS mulit-purpose w/safety tips $5.10 The precision cutting blades with rounded,curved safety tips are made from fine raw materials,tempered,hypoallergenic stainless steel used for surgical instruments,hardened for extra-strength and enhanced with chromium for superior rust protection…. |
|
|
Multi Use Self Seal Freezer Bags – Pack of 25. Multi Use Self Seal Freezer Bags – Pack of 25…. |
|
|
Multi Sport Practice Net – Baseball, Softball, Soccer, Football, Golf $139.00 Take your training to new levels with the Sport Shot multi sports net. Designed to be easy to set up and take down so you can begin practice sessions in minutes. Large opening with hanging targets allows for multiple training strategies. Strong and durable netting with added safety net sewn in for added durability…. |
|
|
Leatherman 830040 New Wave Multi-Tool with Nylon Sheath $93.00 The Wave multitool’s compact folded shape hides a wealth of tools and blades within. The Wave Multitool From Leatherman: Better than Ever The most popular full-size Leatherman tool is now better than ever. Larger knives, stronger pliers, longer wire cutters and all-locking blades make the new Wave an essential piece of equipment for any job or adventure. The pliers have been redesigned to wi… |
|
|
Porter-Cable PC250MTK 2.5 Amp Oscillating Multi-Tool Kit with 36 Accessories $89.00 Porter-Cable’s PC250MTK 2.5-amp oscillating multi-tool kit has been specially designed to offer remodelers, carpenters, general contractors, and a number of other professionals the quality and control they need to complete a variety of applications. From cutting wood, drywall, and nails to removing grout to scraping paint and caulk, the PC250MT oscillating multi-tool tackles a wide variety o… |
|
|
Dremel 565 Multi Purpose Cutting Kit 565D $8.90 Spiral Guide Cutting Kit, Includes 2 Drywall Cutting Bits & 1 Multi Purpose Cutting Bit, Cuts Fiberglass Wood & Drywall Easily…. |
Comment